A Wife’s Meditation on Her Husband’s Death

At Friends of Children awards gala, May 26, 2022
By Carolyn Newberger, widow of classmate Eli Newberger
Eli died last autumn, on October 24, 2024. I was lying by his side, stroking his tummy and his chest as his breathing became more and more gurgly and louder and louder, as though he were breathing through a barrel of water, which perhaps in a way he was. I had queued up Spotify to Louis Armstrong, his favorite and his inspiration. Louis and Ella Fitzgerald were singing Gershwin as I listened to Eli’s rapid shallow breaths as his lungs filled up.
At one point, I rose up and looked him in the face, his eyes closed and his mouth agape. “Eli, I love you,” I said, “You can let go.”
I lay back down and continued to stroke him. As Louis and Ella were singing “Let’s call the whole thing off,” Eli’s breathing just quietly stopped. There was no drama, no noise, just silence.
Eli was my first and only boyfriend. We met when we were 19 and married as undergraduates. We grew up together.

Eli, Carolyn, and granddaughter Leila
You see, people exist in layers. Sometimes those who strive for the greatest accomplishments are those who are trying to overcome the greatest hurts. If they have the talents, the tenacity, and the opportunities, they can do great things.
Such was the case with Eli. We have been married for 62 years. Some of those years have been marked by unhappiness, anger, betrayal, and even separation. He was deeply kind and caring but could also be opinionated and self-righteous. I endlessly tried and endlessly failed to teach him to let other people be more the center of attention.
And yet we stayed the course, through a terrain of hills and valleys and gulfs in between, and I am so grateful. Ours was a marriage full of meaningful accomplishment, partnership, mutual challenge, growing honesty, and the surprisingly deep satisfaction of circling around imperfections and keeping at it.
On May 26, 2022, Eli received the Champion of Children award from the Northampton child advocacy organization, Friends of Children. Their director asked me to introduce Eli before they presented his award. Perhaps those words, unknowingly so close to the end of his life, are a fitting way to end this meditation, a meditation that is not just about Eli, but about life.
Carolyn Newberger’s Introduction of Eli Newberger
Friends of Children Gala
May 26, 2022
I have just been reading Wendell Berry’s marvelous collection of stories about a Kentucky farming community through the 20th century. In one of the stories, a young farmer in a land auction was unexpectedly able to acquire the farm on which he had been a tenant. Responding to the younger man’s incredulity at his good fortune, an older farmer reasoned: “The way you got in it, I guess, was by being chosen. The way you stay in it is by choice.” (“It Wasn’t Me, 1953”)
I was struck by that comment because it could describe the trajectory of Eli’s life both as a musician and as an advocate for children.
Tuba:
The joke among tuba players is that nobody chooses the tuba; the tuba chooses them. This was certainly true for Eli. At age 10, his elementary school music teacher, Doc Randall, was on the lookout for a sturdy boy who would eventually be able to carry a sousaphone in the high school marching band. He opened a closet in the band room, pointed to the mammoth instrument within and asked, “How would you like to play the tuba?”
The tuba having chosen him, Eli fell in love, and in a few years the band master, a French horn player, said, “I’ve taught you all I can teach you. You should study with a tuba teacher.” He suggested that Eli call William Bell, who just happened to be the tubist with the New York Philharmonic.
Eli took the train into Manhattan to audition for Mr. Bell, who said, “I’ll teach you, kid, for $5 an hour, but you have to get a real tuba, an upright C with 4 valves.” Eli replied that there was no way his family or the school could afford such a tuba, thanked him, and got up to leave. Whereupon Mr. Bell said, “Don’t worry, kid. Just bring your mouthpiece next time and I’ll loan you one of mine.” And in return, Eli practiced his heart out to show Mr. Bell that he was worthy of his generosity.
Career path:
We’re here to celebrate Eli’s work as an advocate for children. And there, too, his calling chose him.
In five days, Eli and I will celebrate our 60th wedding anniversary, so I was with him from age 19 on. I remember our walks on the Yale campus, discussing his future options. He was a music theory and composition major, and music is in his bones. But Eli’s mother was schizophrenic and his father largely absent. Eli felt that he had to protect his younger brother and sister and was constantly worried about his mother’s delusional and volatile mental state. As we dated and then quietly wed, Eli’s mother had multiple hospitalizations. Our weekends usually included a trip to visit her in an upstate New York psychiatric institution.
During our walks, Eli closed in on medicine, not least because of his personal experience of being a child with responsibilities beyond his years, a sick mother, and no one who helped them. He wanted to become someone who could help families like his.
Neurology to Pediatrics
Eli’s plan after medical school and an internship at Yale, was a neurology residency at Stanford, but the Peace Corps in West Africa intervened. There he discovered how much he loved caring for children and their mothers in his clinic. Pediatrics found him, and he came to Children’s Hospital for his residency.
Child Abuse and Family Protection
During Eli’s internship, he learned about the murder of a child who had been previously hospitalized, had been reported as a probable case of child abuse to child protective services, yet had been sent home. Concerned about how such a tragedy could occur to a Children’s Hospital patient, he pulled the records of all the children who had been reported to protective services from the inpatient services of Children’s Hospital in the previous year. Eli discovered that of 39 children, four had been readmitted with new signs of abuse, in addition to this murdered child.
Eli called the physician-in-chief of the hospital, Charles Janeway, who asked him if he could bring those records immediately to his office. Dr. Janeway said, “Thank God someone was watching,” and asked Eli to find out what other hospitals were doing and to make a report to the patient care committee.
With a small grant to study other programs in this nascent field, Eli reported to the patient care committee that the most productive hospital approach appeared to be an interdisciplinary team with community agency participation. To his surprise, the committee asked Eli, a 29-year-old pediatric resident, to organize such a program. This led to a clinic, to many research initiatives and publications, a 20-year training program, the first battered women’s advocacy program in a pediatric hospital, and to a field-changing reconsideration of issues of causality, including misogyny, poverty, and racism.
The problem found him, and he stayed in it by choice.
Dale Carnegie, a son of Missouri farmers who later became an advice guru, is famous for saying, among other things,
Success is getting what you want. Happiness is wanting what you get.
In our culture, what typically comes to mind as success is wealth, or fame, or prestige, or power. Success on these terms has never guided Eli. Rather, his guiding forces have been from the inside out: responding to the vulnerability of being a child growing up with a mentally ill mother; being moved by the women and children he treated in his African clinic; being alarmed by the re-injuries of children who came to Children’s Hospital for care, being motivated by injustices that cry for correction or systems that fail people.
How can I describe Eli? As a husband he is loving, supportive of me as a whole person, willing to admit fault and to make amends when called for, and deeply caring of his family. In the world beyond, he is creative, generous, compassionate, and dedicated. If others are in need, he gives unstintingly of his time, influence, expertise, or treasure. For 30 years at Children’s Hospital, he carried a beeper and was on call 24/7. That is generosity.
Eli continues to serve as an expert on some of the most tragic and complex cases in the country. He only agrees to serve when he has read enough of the record to determine that were side on which he serves to prevail, it would elevate the care and protection of children. These cases can keep him up at night, but he is fearless and tireless in his efforts to correct wrongs that have been done to others.
I feel that it’s fitting to end this introduction, not with my words, but with the words of someone who has been affected by Eli’s work as an advocate. Here is a letter from the grandfather of a child who had been separated from her mother after the mother was accused of fabricating the symptoms of the child’s rare disease. The child is now back with her mother and the grandfather writes:
“May 5, 2022
“Dr. Newberger,
“We so wish we could attend the 2022 Friends of Children Gala in Boston to see you honored for your amazing advocacy for the care and protection of children. On behalf of (and here he names the family members) we simply say we fully experienced the decency, grace, compassion, and expertise of you through each and every interaction. We wish we could stand atop a table and sing your praises. We hope and pray that the May 26th Gala is a special blessing for you.
“Again, thank you for everything! We love and adore you.”
Rest in Peace, dearest Eli.
Please leave comments below, if you wish.

Thank you, Carolyn.
I was Eli’s “neighbor” in the New Haven Symphony, as I was the last string bass player and
stood next to the tuba player. We were classmates. He was a splendid player and a lovely
man, and I’m not at all surprised that he led such an admirable life.
I got to know Eli freshman year at Yale University because we played in the same band called the Tin Rainbow Jazz band for four years from 1958 to 1962. I was the tenor banjo player in the group. Since we were members of the same senior Society we have stayed in pretty close touch ever since. Also, I had a sister in Boston so I got up there often.
Eli was a brilliant physician and an outstanding musician. We continued to play together occasionally with his group called Eli’s All Stars. For past ten or so years our Society would have a zoom call every other month and so we stayed in touch. Eli was a wonderful guy and a wonderful friend. We will all miss him very much.
Dudley
Dear Carolyn, Thank you for sharing your beautiful salute to Eli. I was one of his roommates freshman year. If I hadn’t known it before, your tribute would have settled it that I hardly knew him, but was completely right to like him. Thanks to you, now I know a lot better who we’re missing. He gave a wonderful life.
While Eli was a superb tuba player in many musical forms, his enthusiasm for classical jazz crossed over to early country music and bluegrass. As a bluegrass bassist with the Yale Grey Sky Boys we often found each other at jazz and old time music jams, well into graduate school when he was a housemaster at the International House on Prospect Street. His boisterous, wonderfully precise playing gave me plenty of inspiration and ideas for my own playing, and how the rhythm end evolved from the tuba to the string bass in classical commercial jazz.
Dear Mrs. Neuberger,
I graduated in ’58 from A.B. Davis with Eli. As a 15 year old, I did not expand my limited circle of friends to get to know others–including Eli. I deeply regret this decision today as I am priviledged to read of Eli’s many accomplishments and saddened to hear of his passing. His dedication to those of child abuse must have been the most rewarding. We have certainly lost a remarkable and caring advocate.